NOTICE OF COPYRIGHT: This technical tip is copyrighted 2000 by Noel
Charonnat, with all rights reserved, and may not be copied, reproduced
or electronically stored, duplicated or transmitted, in whole or in
part, without written permission; however, for personal non-commercial
use by individual consumers, it may be copied or electronically stored,
duplicated or transmitted provided the copyright notice is retained with
the copy, duplication, or transmission.
|
|||
|
|||
FLUORINATED WAXES
by Noel Charonnat Regular ski waxes are made from long chains of carbon atoms (like a
string of beads). Each carbon atom also has a couple of hydrogen atoms
attached, and as such, these compounds are called hydrocarbons. There
are three different types of waxes which are blended together to make
regular ski waxes: paraffins, microcrystalline, and synthetic waxes. Paraffins are softer candle-like waxes made up of linear strings of
20 to 35 carbon atoms. Paraffins provide low friction coefficients,
meaning that they slide very well across the snow crystals. However,
paraffin waxes tend to break under pressure. Microcrystalline waxes are branched hydrocarbons containing 25 to 50
carbon atoms. They have a higher coefficient of friction than paraffins
but are more elastic ("plastic") and resilient under pressure.
Both paraffin and microcrystalline waxes are derived from petroleum and
are the major components of ski waxes. Waxes formulated for warm snow conditions are blends of softer
paraffins and microcrystalline waxes. Soft waxes have a lower
coefficient of friction, easily sliding across rounded snow crystals and
repelling water more effectively than hard waxes. Colder snow,
especially when freshly fallen, has sharp pointed crystals which tend to
penetrate softer waxes causing the skis to stick to the snow. Waxes
designed for colder snow contain paraffins and microcrystalline waxes
with longer chains of carbon atoms and are thus harder and more
resistant to penetration by snow crystals. Synthetic waxes are the third type of hydrocarbons used in the
production of ski waxes. They are composed of slightly branched chains
of 50 or more carbon atoms, are very hard and brittle and are used as
hardeners for paraffin waxes. Start Green is the perfect example of a
wax that contains a lot of synthetic wax. Waxes for very cold snow
protects the ski bases by flaking away after being penetrated by the
snow. Fluorocarbon waxes started to be developed for skis waxes in the
1980's. Fluorocarbons differ from hydrocarbons in that fluorine atoms
have replaced the hydrogen on the carbon atoms. Fluorine, containing a
dense layer of electrons around its nucleus, is the most
electro-negative of all atoms. The oxygen atom of a water molecule also
has an electron dense negatively charged portion around its nucleus.
Fluorocarbon waxes work because the negatively charged fluorine atoms
and negatively charged oxygen portion of the water molecule repel each
other (like charges repel, such as with the similar poles of two
magnets). It is important to remember that fluorocarbons repel liquid
water. Colder snow has less "free moisture" (liquid water
around the ice crystals), while warm snow has a lot of free moisture.
Thus, fluorocarbon waxes work best in warmer moist snows and in colder
snows only when the humidity is high (above 60-70%). The first fluorocarbon used in ski waxes, as an additive, was Teflon,
(also known as PTFE, or polytetrafluoroethylene). In addition to its
water repellent properties, PTFE is an excellent solid lubricant having
one of the lowest coefficients of friction known. Unfortunately, PTFE
lacks mechanical strength and does not hold up well to colder,
aggressive snow. Also, since PTFE contains over 500 polymerized carbon
atoms, it has a melting point much higher than polyethylene ski bases
and cannot be used as a traditional ski wax to be melted into the pores
of a ski base. As such, PTFE has been mostly limited to use in surface
coat waxes, such as Maxiglide, and a few race waxes and additives (like
Ski-Go 280) which again mostly stay on the surface of the ski. In the late 80's, ski wax companies started to use fluorocarbon
technology originally developed for painting the bottoms of boats and
ships. Swix's Cera-F (properly pronounced "ché - ra", with a
"ch" like in cheese and the "e" like a long
"a" in English), was the first such commercially available
ski-wax. Technically, these waxes are known as perfluorocarbons, with
"per" meaning that all of the hydrogen atoms on the carbon
chain have been replaced with fluorine atoms. These molecules contain
about 20 carbons atoms, and melt at a low enough temperature that they
could be ironed onto the ski without melting the base. Fluorocarbon waxes have the advantages of having a very high degree
of water repellency plus a very low friction coefficient. In addition,
they repel dirt particles (which tend to be negatively charged) and
resist oil (from grooming machines) and waxy pollen from trees. As such,
fluorocarbon waxes are excellent for Spring, when snow tends to be both
wet and dirty. Fluorocarbon waxes, however, have several drawbacks. First of all,
their manufacturing process (by electro fluorination) is complex and
very costly. There are only a couple manufacturing plants (of the raw
materials) and processing laboratories in the entire world. Ski wax
companies do not manufacture their own fluorocarbon wax, but rather buy
these products from the same processing labs. Just like paraffins and PTFE, fluorocarbon waxes also lack mechanical
strength and are thus easily penetrated by cold snow crystals. As such,
fluorocarbon waxes tend to "stick" in temperatures below 21°F,
especially if the humidity is low or the snow is dry. In the last
several years, the processing labs have developed different fluorocarbon
wax structures, often combined with other atoms, to increase the
mechanical strength and temperature ranges. For example, STAR now has
three different fluorocarbons: F1 (powder or solid) for new warmer snow,
F2 (powder or solid) for older (corned) warmer snow, and F3 (powder
only) for colder humid conditions, plus their new "Dice" pure
fluorocarbon rub-on solids, again in three temperature ranges. That's a
total of 8 different pure fluorocarbon waxes from just one wax company! When fluorocarbon waxes were first introduced, the application method
had several limitations. Since pure fluorocarbon do not like to mix with
hydrocarbon waxes, the wax was either applied by rubbing it into the ski
base or applied with a very hot iron. The rub-on "cold method"
worked well for short distance races (like alpine), but since the
fluorocarbon wax did not bind with the underlayer of hydrocarbon wax, it
wore off very fast. The hot iron method, designed to sear a layer into
the top pores of the ski base, causes noxious fumes. The
"sparkles" that appear behind the hot iron is the fluorocarbon
wax being sublimated - literally going from solid to vapor state.
Studies have shown that breathing wax vapors can cause short term loss
of lung function of 10 to 25%. (No long term studies have been
conducted.) The hot iron application method also plugs the pores of the
ski base, which must be peeled before it will accept other waxes. For
the health of both lungs and skis, the hot iron method of application
should be avoided. Fluorinated waxes have lower coefficients of friction and repel water
better than hydrocarbon waxes. However, the wax must contain at least 3%
fluorinated paraffin to show any benefit, and 10-15% for optimum
results. Some "low concentrate" waxes on the market contain
less than 1% - the fluoro benefit of these waxes is simply marketing
fantasy. Price is not always a reflection of fluoro content as some
brands simply charge more. The terms low, medium or high should be used
only to compare fluoro content between different models of wax in the
same brand. One company's low fluor line may actually contain more fluor
than another company's mid-fluor line, and cost less! Some companies
have (and continue to) put PTFE additive in their waxes and imply that
it's really a fluorinated hybrid. Unfortunately, there is way too much
marketing hype in the wax industry. Always keep in mind that, even in the most highly fluorinated bar of
wax, there is 85% or more of paraffins, microcrystalline and synthetic
hydrocarbon waxes, plus other additives. Furthermore, the temperature
and snow conditions may dictate that a higher fluorinated wax is NOT the
best choice. A good rule for selecting a fluorinated glide wax is to err
on the cold (harder wax) side. The hardness can accomodate any
abrasiveness in the snow, and the fluoro content will handle any
moisture, even if the snow warms up and has more moisture. If on the
cusp between two waxes, choose the colder wax. Application of fluorinated waxes is by melting them into the base
with an iron. There are no fumes as associated with ironing pure
fluorocarbons. Fluorinated waxes melt in like regular waxes. Apply a
thin layer and melt in briefly. If the major component is softer
paraffin, then let the wax cool to room temperature before scraping and
brushing off the excess. If the major component of the fluorinated wax
is harder microcrystalline or synthetic waxes, then scrape and brush the
ski base when the wax is still warm. If the wax chips off, that means it
should have been scraped warm. Just re-heat briefly, scrape and brush. After the skis have cooled, use a roto brush with light pressure to
brush out any remaining wax from the structure of the base and polish it
to a nice shine. Harder waxes polish more than softer waxes. The skis
should have no wax on the surface, but feel waxy (in the base) when
rubbed with a thumb. If a pure fluorocarbon is to be applied as a final coat, always use a
high fluoro content fluorinated wax first. It is best to start with a
coat of pure hydrocarbon soft wax. This cleans the base and gets the
pores of the base saturated with hydrocarbon wax. Scrape and brush warm.
Next, use the high fluoro content fluorinated wax, preferably two coats.
Since hydrocarbon and fluorocarbons do not mix, the hydrocarbon end of
these hybrid wax molecules will tend to be aligned into the pores of the
base, while the fluorocarbon ends will be pointed up to the surface.
When the pure fluorocarbon is applied, it will stick to these
fluorocarbon ends just under the surface. e e e e e Here are some recommendations based on using and selling various
fluorinated waxes over the past 10 years at Sierra Nordic: STAR Wax Company (Asiago, Italy) makes the most complete and diverse
line of glide waxes available: 4 basic lines, plus base waxes, top
waxes, cold weather additives, iron in and rub on pure fluorocarbon
waxes, irons, tools, guides, and excellent instructions in the boxes of
their better waxes. The Ultra Tech waxes, their low-fluor line, contains
5 time more fluoro content than other brands yet is less expensive and
yields wondereful glide in most snow conditions. There are only 3 waxes
in this line (which can be blended), which makes glide waxing simple. Star's Tekno line contains 5 excellent glide waxes, two of which are
very unique: TF10 is the best wax we have ever found for dirty Spring
snow conditions. The next colder wax, TF12 is formulated for moist snow
but lower humidity and crosses the 0°C point well. The base waxes from
Star, MAP Black and MAP 200, are the best base waxes on the market.
Their line of DICE rub-on pure fluorocarbon waxes have proven superior
to all other products. Finally, they have brought back their Eclipse
line of glide waxes (because of overwhelming World Cup demand based on
the wax's durability in longer races). RODE is the other (and older) wax company in Asiago. They have always been known for their exceptional line of kick waxes. After the death of founder Rizzieri ("Rode") Rodeghiero several years ago, his son Giuliano took the helm and has developed two new lines of incredible glide waxes. The FS (fluorinated skate) have constantly tested as fast or faster than other brand's best waxes, yet cost about half as much. New this year is the super fluoro content K72 line for higher humidity and wet snow conditions. e |